Rethinking Management: The Imperative for Soft HRM in a Post-Pandemic World

 

The COVID-19 pandemic has incredibly affected many sectors, including individuals, cities, economies, countries, and continents. COVID-19 has compelled managers to make very rapid decisions on who should stay at work, how to move people into digital space, and how to communicate priorities to employees. Ernst & Young LLP (EY US) surveyed 500 board members and CEOs of companies around the world in 2019 and found that only 21 percent of them believed their companies were ready to respond to any unfavorable risk (McWilliams, 2020). A few short months later, the COVID-19 pandemic crisis arrived and proved that these concerns were well founded. This crisis was able to highlight the concerns about the helplessness of the world supply chain, its financial resilience, and strategic human talent. This pandemic shifted the global workforce to remote work, hybrid models, and changing employee needs which once adapted traditional Hard HRM models for efficiency and productivity. It was criticized for a lack of concern for employee well-being and long-term job satisfaction during this pandemic crisis (Peoplegoal, 2021). BCG termed the COVID-19 pandemic a "people-based crisis" (Strack, et al., 2020) that has brought into sharp light the role of HR so often described as soft. Chief people officers have to maintain employee health and morale, oversee remote working, and even contemplate layoffs as firms retrench. The derivation is, therefore, the movement toward adopting the Soft HRM approach that is empathetic and whence employees become centric.

The article will emphasize the soft HRM in the post-COVID era focusing on its significance in enhancing engagement, retention, and productivity among employees. It enumerates that what organizations need to do is give emotional and psychological priority, build trust, and provide work environments that will permit growth in a personal and professional way.

The Need for Soft HRM in the Post-Pandemic World

The COVID-19 pandemic shifted HRM from performance-based to empathetic, flexible, and people-oriented practices, emphasizing employee well-being, trust, development, and engagement, contrasting with traditional performance metrics and policy-based approaches. Thus, soft HRM has turned out to be one of the critical factors in building a sustainable, resilient, and emotionally supportive workplace (Bieńkowska, et al., 2022). This is not a trend, but a fundamental role player in work-life balance and resilience since reshaped expectations made it a challenging and complex environment for managers and HR professionals alike. For instance, millions of US workers were still leery about coming back to work despite COVID-19 vaccines which made it difficult for American organizations to recruit, engage, and retain qualified workers leading to 9.6 million jobs becoming vacant by September 2023 (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2023).

Therefore, COVID-19 has widely influenced the performance of an organization and the policies and practices of human resource management. Human resources are significant assets and sources of competitive advantage. Human resource management notably encompasses planning, organizing, direction, and control of functions of human resources such as staffing, training, performance evaluation, pay, benefits, and workplace safety. In conducting or carrying out HR functions, proper HR policies and practices need to be considered, including shifting employee expectations, impacts of remote and hybrid work, and sustainability and retention.

Issues and Criticisms of Soft HRM

Although the soft type of HRM encompasses a remarkable number of advantages, its application within an organization always faces many difficulties. Several concerns and criticisms are addressed, together with ways through which these can be minimized effectively.

The first challenge of soft HRM refers to the fact that it is often resisted by senior management and decision-makers, who are more accustomed to traditional forms of HRM practices. These practices essentially maintain their focus on performance measures, efficiency, control, and short-term results, usually with high levels of emphasis on cost-cutting and productivity. The set of factors that creates resistance is rounded out by cultural inertia and a focus on metrics and short-term gains. Traditional approaches to HRM are more likely to focus on financially based measures, such as levels of cost reduction or productivity improvement, which may raise doubts regarding the return on investment within the softer HRM practices (Gill, 1999).

Demonstrating how soft HRM aligned with longer-term business objectives will help overcome resistance through education and awareness. It will be prudent for organizations to try and test the impact of soft HRM in small-scale initiatives, such as flexible working policies or employee recognition programs since the change is hard to implement at a larger scale within organizations. In this way, proof of concept can be developed, which will aid in gaining confidence in senior management (Rumman & Alqudah, 2024).

In addition to the above-mentioned challenge, Soft HRM within the realm of employee well-being and engagement has received considerable criticism on the premise that it may water down the focus on short-term business objectives that pertain to increasing profitability or market share (Gill, 1999). Most managers are concerned that it could reduce the emphasis on operational efficiencies or profit-driven bottom-line outcomes and might ultimately hurt the short-term financial performance of the firm. In addition, soft HRM practices such as flexibility, work-life balance, and telecommuting can result in temporary falls in productivity as workers adapt to new systems or ways of working.

Such reconciliation of soft HRM with business objectives involves linking employee engagement with business outcomes, measuring long-term ROI, and balancing flexibility with performance. HR teams may have to collaborate with the finance and senior management teams to come up with metrics that capture the long-term ROI of the investments in soft HRM initiatives. This balance between flexibility and performance includes the use of flexible work policies by making employees accountable for the outcomes, enhancing employee autonomy and well-being, and yet keeping them aligned with the objectives of the business (Bailey, et al., 1997).

Despite its many benefits, soft HRM often meets considerable opposition from senior management concerned with the potential effects it can have on employee welfare and, subsequently, employee engagement. In implementing soft HRM, organizations should seek to demonstrate how soft HRM aligns with longer-term business objectives, test the impact in small-scale initiatives, balance flexibility with performance, and require collaboration with the finance and senior management teams for the capture of long-term ROI.

Success Through Soft HRM

Soft HRM is the approach that concerns people; it is an approach that cares about the well-being of the employees, their engagement in the work, and their development in order to build an enabling positive culture of organizations and enhance satisfaction and performance within big technological companies, as well as startups.

Google is famous for its work culture in making its employees happy and engaged. It provides flexible work arrangements, work from home, and gives ample time for vacation in order to maintain the work-life balance in order. Employees work 20% of their time on what they feel passionate about, be it outside their core job. In addition to these large facilities, each Google campus features on-site wellness centers that offer mental health resources, including therapy. Diversity, equity, and inclusion at Google create a generally positive atmosphere where people feel supported and valued (CulturePartners, 2024).

Besides, Google was able to extend working from home for employees until at least July, making it the first major US company to do so and extending remote work policies into next year because of the coronavirus pandemic. This is from a decree affecting almost 200,000 full-time and contract workers across Alphabet Inc. and has the potential to affect other technology giants that had planned to return staff this January of this year (Gurchiek, 2023).

However, Google increased its revenues by 41 percent in 2021 from $182.53 billion in 2020 to $257.63 billion, whereas 81 percent of the total revenues came from advertisement revenue (GlobalData, n.d.). Thereby, it is evident that combining HR policies with Soft HRM does not impact negatively the organization rather it increases revenue, employee autonomy, and creativity ushering in increased job satisfaction and increased productivity leading to major innovations such as Gmail and Google News; thus, proving the link between employee freedom, on-site engagement, and productivity (CulturePartners, 2024).

With one of the lowest employee turnovers in the tech industry, where 57% would not leave even for more money, 80% are excited to go to work each day, and 69% feel the company is doing what it is supposed to be doing, while 31% may consider new employment, Google surely proves that with a supportive environment comes attractive benefits, which are vital in retaining employees (Google, 2024).

Not only do tech giants like Google adopt people-centric HR policies and practices, but also Patagonia (Castillo, 2020), Zappos (Benton, 2022), and many more big technological companies and startups integrate and implement Soft HRM policies to achieve higher levels of employee commitment and retention which ultimately enhances the well-being of employees, work-life balance, empowerment, and continuous development leading to high performance, innovation, and organizational success.

Conclusion

The COVID-19 pandemic has brought a change in the concept of HRM from performance-oriented to empathetic, flexible, and people-oriented practices. This shift gives more focus on employee well-being, trust, development, and engagement than traditional metrics of performance and policy-based approach. Soft HRM is very essential in constructing a sustainable, resilient, and emotionally supportive work environment with proper work-life balance for resilience. Organizations will need to focus on emotional and psychological well-being, build trust, and offer work environments that can facilitate personal and professional growth.

Despite deriving many benefits from soft HRM, the resistance at the senior management level is also very well understood, as their ultimate focus is on short-term results and measurements. In such a scenario, organizations should communicate how soft HRM addresses the long-term goals of the business, replicate the effectiveness of soft HRM on a smaller scale, ensure flexibility with performance, and involve the finance and senior management teams to bury the skeletons. The soft approach towards HRM would bring about an improved work culture, which means a guarantee of higher satisfaction and performance from the employees. Indeed, Google has brought about soft HRM concerning flexible working hours, work-from-home facilities, and vacation time; the atmosphere is pretty good at work, and it allows working from home.

 

 

References

Bailey, C., Gratton, L., Hope-Hailey, V. & McGovern, P. G., 1997. Soft and Hard Models of Human Resource Management: A Reappraisal. Journal of Management Studies, pp. 53-73.

Benton, L., 2022. Zappos – The Culture Everyone Wants to Copy. [Online]
Available at: https://libertymind.co.uk/zappos-the-culture-everyone-wants-to-copy/
[Accessed 7 November 2024].

Bieńkowska , A., Koszela, A., Sałamacha , A. & Tworek, K., 2022. COVID-19 oriented HRM strategies influence on job and organizational performance through job-related attitudes. PLoSONE, pp. 1-29.

Castillo, K., 2020. Inside Patagonia’s Corporate Culture That Prioritizes Flexibility and Work-Life Balance. [Online]
Available at: https://www.futureofbusinessandtech.com/employee-wellbeing/inside-patagonias-corporate-culture-that-prioritizes-flexibility-and-work-life-balance/
[Accessed 7 November 2024].

CulturePartners, 2024. Google’s Company Culture: Unveiling Organizational Values. [Online]
Available at: https://culturepartners.com/insights/googles-company-culture-unveiling-organizational-values/
[Accessed 7 November 2024].

Gill, C., 1999. Working Paper Series Use of Hard and Soft Models of HRM to illustrate the gap between Rhetoric and Reality in Workforce Management. s.l.:RMIT Business.

GlobalData, n.d.. Google’s Revenue (2002 - 2021). [Online]
Available at: https://www.globaldata.com/data-insights/internet-services-technology-media-and-telecom/googles-revenue/#:~:text=Google's%20Revenue%20(2002%2D2021%2C%20%24%20billion)&text=Google%2C%20the%20search%20engine%20giant,revenues%20in%202021%20from%20advertiseme
[Accessed 7 November 2024].

Google, 2024. Google Retention Score. [Online]
Available at: https://www.comparably.com/companies/google/retention
[Accessed 7 November 2024].

Gurchiek, K., 2023. Google Extends Work-from-Home Policy Through June 2021. [Online]
Available at: https://www.shrm.org/mena/topics-tools/news/technology/google-extends-work-home-policy-june-2021
[Accessed 7 November 2024].

McWilliams, L., 2020. Nearly 80% of Board Members Felt Unprepared for a Major Risk Event Like COVID-19: EY survey. [Online]
Available at: https://publish-ey-prod-cdn.adobecqms.net/en_us/news/2020/04/nearly-80-percent-of-board-members-felt-unprepared-for-a-major-risk-event-like-covid-19-ey-survey
[Accessed 7 November 2024].

Peoplegoal, 2021. HRM Post-COVID: The Evolution of Human Resources Management. [Online]
Available at: https://www.peoplegoal.com/blog/human-resources-management-post-covid
[Accessed 7 November 2024].

Rumman, M. A. A. & Alqudah, E., 2024. The Impact of Green HRM on Lean Soft Practices Implementation: A Mediating Role of Organizational Flexibility. Global Journal of Flexible Systems Management.

Strack, R. et al., 2020. People Priorities in Response to COVID-19. [Online]
Available at: https://www.bcg.com/publications/2020/people-solutions-response-covid
[Accessed 7 November 2024].

Tessema, M. . T. et al., 2024. Human Resource Management in the Post-Pandemic Era, the Case of the United States of America. Global Journal of Human Resource Management, 12(2), pp. 112-130.

U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2023. Job Openings and Labor Turnover - September 2023. [Online]
Available at: https://www.bls.gov/news.release/archives/jolts_11012023.pdf
[Accessed 7 November 2024].